The Issue
Insurance coverage for abortions in the health
care legislation.
The Fight
Abortion opponents want tight restrictions on
coverage for abortions, including a ban on coverage for any health plan that is
purchased even partly with new federal subsidies intended to help
moderate-income Americans buy insurance. Advocates for abortion rights
acknowledge that Congress will not allow federal money to be used to pay for
abortions, but they do not want any restrictions beyond those in existing law,
which bar the use of tax dollars for abortions with exceptions for rape, incest
or the motherfs health.
The House Bill
The health care legislation approved last
month by the House includes tight restrictions on insurance coverage for
abortions. The restrictions were included in an amendment, sponsored by
Representative Bart Stupak, Democrat of Michigan, that was approved just before
final passage of the bill after negotiations between abortion opponents and
supporters of abortion rights broke down.
The Senate Bill
The bill now being debated on the Senate
floor includes language intended to preserve a federal law, known as the Hyde
amendment, which bars the use of federal dollars for abortions except in rare
cases. The Senate bill would require that at least one government-approved
health plan in each state cover abortions and that at least one
government-approved health plan in each state not cover abortions. Only premiums
paid privately by beneficiaries could be used to pay for abortions. Insurance
plans would be required to segregate that money to ensure that no tax dollars
are used for abortions.
The Debate
Senator Ben Nelson, Democrat of Nebraska and
an opponent of abortion rights, is preparing an amendment that would largely
adopt the Stupak language as part of the Senate bill. To do so, Mr. Nelson and
his supporters will need to win the votes of at least 60 senators. Liberal
Democrats, who support abortion rights and vehemently oppose the Stupak
language, are confident they have the votes to defeat the Nelson amendment.
Debate is expected to begin Monday afternoon.
Lawmakers to Watch
Mr. Nelson is leading the effort by
abortion opponents in the Senate. Senators Barbara Boxer, Democrat of
California, and Barbara A. Mikulski, Democrat of Maryland, are among the leaders
of those defending abortion rights. Among the Democrats expected to back Mr.
Nelsonfs amendment are Senators Kent Conrad and Byron Dorgan of North Dakota and
Robert C. Byrd of West Virginia. Senator Bob Casey of Pennsylvania, a liberal
and a prominent Catholic who opposes abortion rights, could emerge as a broker
of a deal. Also keep an eye on the Senate majority leader, Harry Reid of Nevada,
who has voted in the past to restrict abortion rights but is under a lot of
pressure by the liberal wing of the party and faces a tough re-election campaign
next year. Republicans expected to oppose the Nelson amendment include Senators
Olympia J. Snowe and Susan Collins of Maine.
Lobbying
Catholic bishops and other opponents of abortion
are urging senators to support Mr. Nelsonfs proposal. Planned Parenthood and
other abortion rights advocates view the Stupak language as a major threat and
are mobilizing large networks of their members.
The Bottom Line
Insurance coverage for abortions is
typically not the top priority of the millions of uninsured Americans, who need
benefits to cover basic, everyday health concerns. But politically the health
care legislation cannot be finalized without a hard-fought compromise on this
deeply divisive and emotional issue.